A Defense of Tourist Traps
“The message is very clear: traveling is good, but don’t get caught being a tourist.”
In the age of modern tourism, the idea of “traveling like a local” has been glorified as the pinnacle of authentic travel experiences. Being elbow-deep in the travel blogger and influencer era, independent DIY travel has become the norm. When researching and planning a trip, you’re likely to encounter articles titled “Non Touristy Underrated Places in Europe to Visit,” and “Tips to Help You Live Like a Local When You Travel.”
The more avid the traveler, the more likely you are to hear this narrative over and over again. You’ll hear phrases such as “off the beaten path,” “hidden gem,” and “like a local.” These overstated and sometimes aggressive themes push you to get an “authentic” experience or see the “real destination” rather than clichéd attractions overrun with tourists. The message is very clear: traveling is good, but don’t get caught being a tourist.
“The notion of “traveling like a local” and poo-pooing the most popular attractions on your vacation can be enticing.”
I am someone who has personally clung onto this travel philosophy with every fiber of my being. I’ve spent hours upon hours scouring TripAdvisor and travel blogs for the lesser-known attractions, patting myself on the back and sitting a little taller on my high horse when my itinerary hits sights that aren’t mentioned in Rick Steeves. And I’ve cringed several paces behind my father as he’s reading aloud from a guidebook in the streets of Rome, praying not to be embarrassed by his blatant tourist-ness… As if any true local within a mile radius couldn’t identify me as an American on sight.
I’ll be honest, the notion of “traveling like a local” and poo-pooing the most popular attractions on your vacation can be enticing. You’re promised to see the spots that only those with the inside scoop can find. If you’re in the know, you’ll get to have experiences that are seemingly under-appreciated by the “tourist trap” visitor. And then you have the power to gatekeep this information until you cross paths with another non-touristy…tourist.
But, what if all that work you’re doing to avoid looking like a tourist is missing the point? Because while “travel like a local” and “avoid tourist traps” advice may have some merit, they can also deter travelers from enjoying the most remarkable aspects of a destination.
First, the myth of the “tourist trap” implies that tourists are being lured into spending more money than the experience is worth, often with the promise of something unique or culturally significant that may not deliver. Like saying that the Sistine Chapel is tainted with every pair of non-Roman eyes that gawk in awe at Michelangelo’s masterpiece, or that buying a crepe on the lawn of the Eiffel Tower makes you a less savvy traveler.
Attractions like Big Ben, the Trevi Fountain, Times Square – these landmarks and their surrounding neighborhoods are undeniably crowded, yes, and they can be expensive. But their popularity stems from their extraordinary appeal. These attractions are iconic for a reason. They encapsulate the history, culture, and spirit of their locales. By dismissing them as mere “tourist traps,” travelers might miss out on the awe-inspiring experiences these sites offer.
“As a visitor, you will always have a different perspective than someone who lives in the area.”
Many so-called tourist traps have deep historical roots. The Colosseum in Rome is a prime example. This ancient amphitheater is not just a massive structure; it’s a testament to the architectural prowess and societal complexities of the Roman Empire. Visiting the Colosseum allows travelers to step back in time and imagine the grandeur of ancient Roman spectacles, from gladiatorial combats to public events. It’s a tangible link to history, offering insights into the culture, engineering, and entertainment of a civilization that has profoundly influenced the modern world. This site is an opportunity to connect with a pivotal piece of human history. Moments like this create lasting memories and provide a sense of wonder and appreciation for the world’s diverse and complex history, innovation, and beauty.
The older I get, the more “travel like a local” seems like the most oxymoronic advice you could ever receive. And I say that fully knowing I unabashedly preached this advice like gospel.
The idea of “traveling like a local” suggests a more authentic, immersive experience. However, the reality is that as a visitor, you will always have a different perspective than someone who lives in the area. Because, here’s the thing – locals aren’t traveling. They are commuting to work, washing dishes, taking out the trash, making grocery lists, or any number of mundane chores that must get done day in and day out. Locals have daily routines, responsibilities, and experiences that are fundamentally different from those as a traveler… the same routines that we look to escape in our own everyday lives through travel. Striving to live exactly like a local can lead to unrealistic expectations and missed opportunities.
“As a traveler, every moment is an opportunity to learn, enjoy, and grow.”
Besides, as long as you’re being respectful to the people, monuments, and culture of your destination, there is nothing wrong with being a tourist. Embracing your role as a visitor allows you to experience the highlights of a location, learn from guided tours, and enjoy the conveniences designed for travelers.
So, rather than exclusively seeking out hidden gems or local haunts, you can blend the popular attractions with lesser-known experiences. Enjoy the grandeur of famous landmarks and then explore nearby neighborhoods to see a different side of your destination. Eat at a popular restaurant one night and try a local street food vendor the next. A balanced approach such as this will lead to a fuller, richer travel experience.
Ultimately, travel is about exploration, discovery, and enjoyment. By dismissing certain attractions as “tourist traps” or overemphasizing the need to “travel like a local,” visitors may underestimate just how much popular attractions can enhance their vacation, and potentially miss out on a wealth of experiences.
The goal of travel is to broaden your horizons, create lasting memories, and gain a deeper understanding of the world. So the next time you plan a trip, don’t shy away from the popular spots – they’re popular for a reason. And remember that as a traveler, every moment is an opportunity to learn, enjoy, and grow.